I absolutely loved this book! Naomi transformed from a once shy and "outsider" child into a strong and confidant friend, sister, and great grandchild. Naomi stood up for herself and what she believed in when it mattered the most, and she came out of her shell at exactly the right time. When the trial was being conducted and the judge was trying to make the final decision, Naomi stood up and proved to the judge that being in her mother's care was not the best place for her to live. Naomi is a girl that is very talented, and she is a girl that has many layers that are waiting to be exposed to the world. Give her a chance to open up, and you will be surprised at what is hiding behind that soft and timid voice. I also believe that the author, Pam Ryan, did an excellent job presenting cultural details, and presenting them naturally as well in the book. The inclusion of the annual La Noche de los Rabanos is an excellent example of integrating cultural details naturally. The festival was presented just as naturally as a Christmas tradition or even a chili cook off competition would be introduced in southern culture. The festival was of great importance to the Leon family, and the inclusion of the festival was a tie to Naomi's father Santiago. This festival and the tie to Santiago also could explain Naomi's talent with soap carving that the reader sees evident throughout the book. I also feel that the author writes with an insider perspective. The author has a mixture Spanish, Mexican, Basque, Italian and Oklahoman background; therefore I believe that she portrays the Mexican cultural aspects authentically, being that she has some Mexican background. I also believe that she portrays the language authentically in the book. Although I do not claim to be fluent in Spanish, I believe that she used the language very effectively, especially for a mostly English speaking audience. The author was also raised in California, which would give her an insider perspective being that she knows a lot about the setting that she was writing about. I also feel that the author uses details accurately, and I feel that this avoids stereotypes because the majority of stereotypes are false. By presenting details accurately, the "real" picture of the culture is presented, and thus for the stereotype is eliminated. The author avoids the stereotype that Mexican or Hispanic individuals are violent and dangerous by providing details about the La Noche de los Rabanos. Everyone was walking down the streets celebrating going from door to door to try new foods and celebrate the unity in the community. The author did not mention any deaths or casualties, and I would believe that during a time of celebration the community would be excited and loving not angry and hate driven. Once again I loved this book! An excellent multicultural book!