After this reading, I couldn't help but think about my own childhood. I have the same "good girl" memories of church, Vacation Bible school, and (I still love it!) Kool Aid. In fact, the memories are so vivid that I can still smell the musty upstairs classroom where my Vacation Bible school class took place. (I loved that smell!) I also remember the strong desire to be a "good girl" to make my mother proud. This desire led me to make alot of "safe" decisions in my life that, looking back, I regret.
My mother never went to college. My grandparents couldn't afford to send their children to college. College, to my mother, was a dream that she would never fulfill. I'm sure that was why it was so important to her that my sister and I attend college. When I graduated from high school, my mother wanted me to attend a community college that offered an extremely limited number of programs. None of these interested me, but this college was my only choice. My mom was afraid for me to "go away" to college. Because she hadn't attended college, she didn't realize that not all colleges and universities were the same. Not wanting to disappoint my mother, I attended the college she chose. It took me almost ten years to return to college and attend the university that I wanted to attend in the first place. My initial "safe" decision took me ten years to "undo."
While reading this chapter, I kep thinking that in our society, especially in the south, the "good girl" image leaves so many girls feeling like they have to please everyone around them. For me it was my mother. It was also my teachers. While this is a good trait in many instances, it is also detrimental. I want my daughter to be a "good girl," but I also want her to be a strong girl who goes after what she wants in life - regardless of my opinion (within reason, of course... hahaha). I want the same for the girls in my classroom. I don't want them to be timid. I want them to have confidence and jump in with both feet, regardless of the consequences.
Laurie made me think of a child I had in my class this year. Her mother warned me about this little girl, I'll call Amy. She said Amy was, basically, a terror who would not follow directions and would disrupt my class. She told me to call her whenever there was a behavior problem and she would "step in" to handle it from home. This conversation made me dread working with the child. I had two children in my class that I was already aware of that had special behavioral challenges. I really didn't want a third. Amy, it turns out, was fine. She was polite in our interactions and was kind with her classmates. I asked her to help in doing various activities in the classroom, which seemed to bolster her self-esteem. The more I gave her to do to help me, the more helpful (and better behaved) she became. It was wonderful! (Her low academic performance also started to improve.) Her mother was shocked to find out about her behavior. To be truthful, I was sad to see the school year end. Amy was such a sweet little girl who thrived on being viewed as a "good girl." Isn't that what all children want?
Comments (4)
I too feel as if I have led a very safe life. I have never been on a vacation without my mother right there beside me and I have never been on a road trip with my friends. The only trip I have ever taken was with the school drama department to New York, N.Y. for 2 days. That was an interesting experience for me. Even though I went away for college I still came home every single weekend for three years because it was only an hour away. Now as I begin to start my life with my fiancé we have decided to build a house. Guess where it is? Less than 100 yards away from my parent’s house. Now of course part of that is because they gave us the land but another part of it is because I didn’t want to move far away. Is this a good thing? Is it a bad thing? I don’t know for sure, but I do know that I wish I had traveled more during summer breaks in college. I do plan to travel a lot with my husband to be when we get married, but you know, sometimes you just need to get out on your own for a while.
~Kristen Billings
Posted by Kristen Billings | June 13, 2007 1:54 PM
Posted on June 13, 2007 13:54
Jeanna,
I too can relate to childhood experiences in church and Bible school. I can relate to the "good girl" because I too was one. I too didn't want to disappoint my mom, but one thing my mom did do is tell me that I had to decide for myself what direction I wanted to go in life. I like that she gave me the opportunity to choose. Even though it took ten years, I am glad you finally got the chance to follow the path you wanted to. It makes me wonder how many students aren't as lucky as you and never get the chance to pursue their dreams.
That was very interesting how Amy turned out to be just fine even though mom thought she would be a problem. It happens so many times that I will compliment a child on their wonderful behavior and mom is shocked and says they are not like that at home. So what is it at home that makes things different? Is is the structure or is it that children just know they can get away with more? Maybe it is the attention they are fighting for at home.
Linda Younts
Posted by Linda Younts | June 13, 2007 5:02 PM
Posted on June 13, 2007 17:02
Taking risks can definitely shift one's perception of oneself. I actually think Laurie positioning herself as a "good girl" could be read as a bit of a risk on her part, especially since it masked so many of her problems. How much she was risking to have what she was trying to hide to be revealed!
Like you mention, being a "good girl" can have many different consequences for many different girls. It's important to always put that back into the context.
Posted by Alecia | June 14, 2007 8:28 PM
Posted on June 14, 2007 20:28
Hello! I appreciate you for the nice statement. Stay the best! :-)
Posted by sleep | April 16, 2011 10:12 PM
Posted on April 16, 2011 22:12