I really was touched by this article for several reasons. First, I was drawn into the methodology of the narrative form (with blended narrative from the author). When articles are laid out in this fashion, they are easier to read...from my perspective. I enjoyed the "back and forth"ness between teachers in the field and the educational researcher because the flow of the writing was smooth and very rythmatic. It displayed humaness and reflective soul work coming from the teachers and insightful (referenced) information from the researcher. It was balanced well between the subjects and the researcher; no one voice stood strong, the teachers and the researchers both produced insight for the reader.
Secondly, I have to admit that I also enjoyed the topic. As a woman educator, I struggled with ALL the topics: nurturer, giver, mother, social worker, advocate, etc. for my students. Perhaps my own burnout from teaching preschool was brought on by what these teachers experienced. This article gave me a voice, as though I had contributed. What was refreshing was that the researcher "heard" and "felt" and made meaning to what was written in reflection. When I taught and felt the same as these teachers, no one was willing to listen. If fact, there were so many of us women feeling the same way that, I guess, it was pointless to dwell on the situation because it wasn't going to change.
Finally, I think that living in the time as we do, we are ALL faced with multiple roles tugging at us; be it in the workplace or at home and in the community. However, in teaching, especially for the professional who holds the profession high, we give and give until we just burnout. I am grateful that these women had a voice that was heard. Perhaps, in continuing ed programs, these issues, especially for women teachers who have been in the field a long time, self-care can be addressed so that teachers don't leave the field like I needed to do.
Diane
Comments (4)
Diane,
Do you think if you had an outlet to talk about how you were feeling it would have prevented burnout or at least lessened the burden?
Posted by Danielle | June 30, 2009 2:11 PM
Posted on June 30, 2009 14:11
I wonder what the difference is between those teachers who never seem to burnout and those who do? Is it as Danielle suggests and those who do not burnout have some outlet? I know some teachers who have less than the greatest work environments and yet they persist and do good work. I suppose we all have some level of burnout at some point in our careers. I can certainly say that one of the reasons I entered administration was burnout- I needed a change and a new challenge.
Posted by Christy Forrest | June 30, 2009 8:59 PM
Posted on June 30, 2009 20:59
I definitely think self-care has a lot to do with burnout in many professions. That could mean having an outlet or taking a vacation or learning how to let go of bad energy. Each of us is different. In counselor-education there is a heavy emphasis on self-care -- it is essential to the work we do, or else we'd all end up with Vicarious Trauma (also Secondary Traumatic Stress...these are real diagnoses.) Maybe teacher education should consider including some mention of self-preservation strategies in the curriculum to try to prevent so many teachers from leaving the field? Does teacher ed already do this?
Posted by marisa | June 30, 2009 9:46 PM
Posted on June 30, 2009 21:46
Diane, after reading your blog, I have two questions for you.
First, knowing what you know now, as it pertains to the multiple roles of women and their need to self - care, how would your new-found understanding impact your level of teaching, if in fact you were teaching today?
Also, what things would you do differently in order to prevent the 'teacher burn out' that you mentioned in your reflection?
According (Quinn 2008) women often times have difficulty balancing their family responsibilities and their work related obligations. Your experiences may be very insightful in assisting other women who find themselves’ in a ‘role strain’.
Any thoughts?
Johnny Smith
Posted by Johnny Smith | June 30, 2009 10:36 PM
Posted on June 30, 2009 22:36