I found the articles a bit more difficult to read than the previous ones, but I understood that in order to reach African American students, you have to find their interests and use those interests as literacy instruction. As I was reading the Henry and Staples articles, I recognized the overwhelming challenge teachers today are facing with educating and sometimes “parenting” these students. Some students do not have any support at home, and school becomes their escape. These are the most difficult students to reach.
Most schools have students with diverse backgrounds and as teachers, our job becomes more difficult. With these varied backgrounds come different languages, different parental support networks, and different cultural differences. As a language arts teacher my job is to reach all of these students and in order to do so, I must make the content relevant to them. While most of them already know how to read when they get to the 8th grade, many do not comprehend what they read. Much of the state testing involves application and analysis surrounding topics they have no prior knowledge. Sometimes the articles on the state tests are gender and racially biased making minority groups disadvantaged.
I am currently teaching in a school that is almost all white. On my team of 110 students this year, only two were African American. Two others were multi-racial, two were Hispanic and six were Asian. I realize that I need to continue to connect the literature that I teach to the students, and by doing so, they thirst for more.
Henry’s article reminded me of a new strategy I tried this year called, Reader’s/Writer’s Workshop. I allowed my students to read anything they wanted. Each week they were to write to me or a peer about what they had been reading. I had them use a series of question stems to help break the habit of always writing a summary. I wanted them to connect to the literature. Years ago when I first started teaching, I was fortunate enough to have a principal purchase a class set of Don’t You Dare Read This, Mrs. Dunphrey by Margaret Peterson Haddix. In this novel, the character has to write in her diary for class, and the teacher collects the journals and reads them for a grade. If a student writes anything personal in the diary, the students can fold over the page and the teacher promises not to read that entry. Remembering this idea, I told my students that if they ever wrote anything private or felt that a connection to a character was too personal, I promised not to read it. I saw huge growth in the reading comprehension skills and writing skills of my students this past year. Out of 110 students, I only had 4 that didn’t pass the reading EOG for 8th grade. What I learned from this is, if we allow them a say in what they read, they will read.
Karen Chester
Comments (5)
It is great how successful your students did on the EOG. I think being able to write in their journal and not have to feel like they are being judged does empower students. Some of us do not feel comfortable speaking in public or cannot get our thoughts together quick enough to verbally say how we feel about something. Just like students from other cultures can feel empowered, so can the student who may not be as vocal. Another key seemed to be creating a safe environment, so the students feel free to open up. I think this readers/writers workshop is a great way to do this.
Trish Edwards
Posted by Trish Edwards | June 14, 2010 7:38 PM
Posted on June 14, 2010 19:38
Karen,
You have a very interesting post here as always. I love Don’t You Dare Read this and I just wanted to say that many of my kids, even as “old” as they are, love it too. It is difficult working in a diverse school, but I think that many of the troubles you see with the select few non- white students you have, probably benefit greatly from your willingness to get into the mud with them. Also, I am a big fan of the reading and writing workshop; I do it with novels like Born Blue by Han Nolan and The Gift Moves by a local author.
William Byland
Posted by William Byland | June 14, 2010 7:40 PM
Posted on June 14, 2010 19:40
Dear Karen,
I couldn't agree with you more about student choice in reading. This year I tried a different approach to guided reading groups. I tried literature circles with my more fluent readers. In literature circles, they were given a choice in what they read and how much they read as a group each night. This increased their comprehension and desire to read just as what you did in your classroom. I liked the idea that you used in your student's jounals of having them fold a page over. That allowed them to express their private thoughts on paper while allowing them their privacy.
Reshawna Greene
Posted by Reshawna Greene | June 14, 2010 8:01 PM
Posted on June 14, 2010 20:01
Karen,
I like your idea for using the Reader’s/Writer’s notebook to keep your students engaged in reading and writing. Can you explain a little more about how you organized and managed this method? Did the students read whatever they wanted regardless of difficulty? Did they always fold the page over so that you never had permission to read it? Did they spend their time reading and writing inside and outside of class?
Laura Corbello
Posted by Laura Corbello | June 15, 2010 4:03 PM
Posted on June 15, 2010 16:03
Karen,
I also let my kids write about whatever they would like. I love the idea about folding over pages that are more personal. I can see how the students would respond better to their teacher when the teacher is respectful of their privacy. I am sure that this is part of the reason your students did so well on their EOG's.
Posted by Erin Whisnant | June 15, 2010 7:16 PM
Posted on June 15, 2010 19:16