I am like Lisa Delpit because I tell my fourteen-year-old son to speak correctly. My famous line is “Keep the street in the street.” I normally receive rolled eyes as a response. Yet, he speaks correctly in the appropriate situation. Am I causing him to feel inadequate in his skin? Have I caused my English Language Learners students to feel inadequate in their skin when I suggest speaking English in a group mixed with English only speakers? Have I caused other students to feel inadequate?
I remember being outraged with California and the Ebonics debate. Why would you want to support the Ebonics curriculum? I remember someone asking me what I thought of the Oakland Policy and I said it was the dumbest thing I have ever heard. I did not research or listen to the reasons for teaching Ebonics. Teachers take conversational Spanish classes in order to understand Spanish students. I believe it could be looked upon as the same.
Language is a reflection of the person speaking. I am guilty of being annoyed with particular dialects and probably questioned the person intellect. I have to think about from an educator’s point of view. I want to encourage and support all my students. If connecting with my students means accepting some ‘street talk’, I will accept the street talk. I wonder if students will become more accepting of Standard English if they are not made to feel insignificant. I think classrooms are changing from traditional teaching to more student centered teaching. If this is the case, student centered teaching will have to be accepting of the cultural background of students.
I have lived in the world of Michelle Obama and Joanne Dowdy. I have been told I talk white. I have had my physical appearance questioned. I live in both worlds and flip between the two. In all honesty, I believe we all code switch—a language for play a language for work.
Zandra Hunt
Comments (2)
Zandra,
I think you are making AWESOME choices. I suggest the same things to my students about having them speak only English in a mixed group mainly because I want them to learn the language. I do not think you are causing anyone to feel inadequate but you are showing them how to speak correctly and one day they will thank you for that.
Natalie
Posted by Natalie Enns | June 8, 2010 10:16 PM
Posted on June 8, 2010 22:16
I remember being disturbed by the Ebonics curriculum as well. However, my reasons were a little different. I grew up in a community that would have been criticized by educated society for our "country" way of speaking. Despite this I had many family members (not that I am proud of it) who jumped on the bandwagon of using Ebonics as an opportunity to make fun of the African American community. I was embarrassed by their way of thinking, but did not draw the connections to the way they saw African Americans and the way others saw "us" until later in my life.
Posted by Christy Laws | June 8, 2010 11:57 PM
Posted on June 8, 2010 23:57