Naomi the Lion... Megan Snyder
This was a great book. I really admire the way Pam Munoz Ryan wrote this book. The entire book is so real. It is written using everyday language and situations that aren’t sugar coated. What I appreciated most about this book is the ending. Children’s literature tends to end in an overly happy, not so realistic way. This book on the other has a happy, but realistic ending. Pam Munoz Ryan could have made the ending to be the stereotypical everyone wins ending. In that ending Naomi, Owen, and Gram would have all moved down to Mexico and started a family with Santiago, which by then would have fallen in love with Graciela. Instead Ryan chose to have Naomi and Owen stay with Gram in Lemon Tree with the possibility of visiting their dad whenever they can on the holidays. It even mentions the possibility that Skyla could come back one day and try again for custody of Naomi. But none of the characters worry themselves with that aspect and they all focus on how lucky they are that things turned out the way they did. Ryan also does a great job of adding Mexican culture into the story. Half of the conversations towards the end of the book are in Spanish and repeated in English. While Naomi is learning Spanish in the story, the readers are learning Spanish as well. There are a few parts in the story, especially at the end when the font changes to italics and it is solely Naomi’s thoughts. To me these seemed like checkpoints in the book. They provided a chance for the reader to step back and think about what all had happened so far and how it might unravel in the future of the story. They also help provide insight into Naomi’s deepest thoughts. Ryan was also successful in creating two believable, hateable, villains, in Skyla and Clive. I began disliking Clive when he ruined Naomi’s soap sculpture. I REALLY began to dislike Skyla when she showed her preference towards Naomi and distaste for Owen. The way she shunned Owen and tried to change him made me furious, especially when she takes him to the hospital and gets mad that the doctors can’t do anything more to help him. Who does she think she is? Any reader can tell that Owen is 100 times more lucky, smart, and happy than Skyla is or will ever be. The fact that Skyla can’t appreciate the joy Owen would bring to her life makes it easy to extremely dislike her. Naomi described her perfectly saying, “It was funny how she was nice in a mean way, and mean in a nice way.” But overall I’d say this was a great book because of its 1)great characters 2)realistic plot line 3)multicultural elements 4)Naomi’s lists.