This chapter had many parts that saddened me. As a Caucasian female, it is difficult for me to truly understand what it must be like for an African American female to grow up. I thought the author really wrote well and made the reader much more aware of her feelings and memories. Society can be so cruel I really felt for Hooks when she was talking about being light skinned and not fully understanding where she fit into the world. I had a similar situation occur in my second grade classroom this year. I have two bi-racial boys in the classroom. They both have light brown skin and seem to be accepted by all students in the room. One of the boy’s mother came to class one day to bring him lunch money. She is Caucasian. A conversation quickly began at this boy’s table about how is that your mother and she is not your same skin color. I quickly changed the conversation and continued with my lesson. I really did not know what to do. The little boy seemed hurt by the conversation and you could tell his mind was racing, I am sure this was his first experience with this kind of attitude with his peers. I decided to incorporate some diversity lessons the following week by using Paideia. This is an open forum type of teaching where conversations and questioning is encouraged. I do think it helped the boy in my classroom and his peers, but more importantly, it gave me some background training/information that I can utilize again and teach immediately if the situation occurs again. Teachable moments are so crucial. It really bothered me that I just did not know what to do. I was taken off guard and that doesn’t happen a lot in a second grade classroom.
One other interesting part of the chapter was the story Hooks told of reading books and experiencing adventure. I regret that I never had the opportunity to enjoy books in that way as a child. I always looked at reading as a chore. I now love to read children’s literature and do it often, but I never enjoyed reading as a child. My mother read a lot and took me to the library often. I would check out huge stacks of books and take them home and return them the following week unread. At times, a few would be read if my mother asked questions, but very often the books just did not even get opened. I have no idea why her love for literature did not rub off on me until I was an adult.
I constantly kept relating this author’s stories to my own childhood. My mother was raised in a house that would be considered a working class family. She raised us in a similar fashion. I really don’t know how to describe what social class my family would be considered. My mother was a homemaker, but was very involved with the church and school. She spent many hours volunteering each week. I really thought of this as her job. My step-father was the sole financial supporter and was very much like Hook’s father. His job was to keep the house running and go to work. My mom’s job was to cook, clean and help the children with schoolwork. It was a comfortable relationship and seemed to work. As an adult, I chose a much different path. My husband and I both work and we jointly take care of the children. This works for me. My mother probably did not want the same home environment as I have. Neither one is right or wrong. They are just both very different. Both environments nurture the child and encourage literacy. Just as Hooks help to mold Laurie into the student she became, I hope to encourage my students and children to read books, write stories and share their lives with each other.
Beth Rigsbee
Comments (5)
Beth,
I read in your post that you didn't experience adventure in books when you were a child and this reminded me of myself as a child. I also saw reading as a chore. My mother always read to me, too. We had lots of books in our home and we went to the library to check out books. My mother loved to read. I, too love to read children's literature as an adult and I have quite a collection. It is so enjoyable to read.
Posted by Dawn Thomas | June 10, 2007 10:46 PM
Posted on June 10, 2007 22:46
Beth,
We all come form homes that are unique and different. As an African American female, I don't think that growing up was any worse for me than any other American. No matter what race a person belongs to, family and community values and practices are factors that can influence a child's physical, social, mental, and spiritual identities. Hooks writes, "...her history as a reader evolved partly in relation to her longing to escape a sometimes lonely, conflicted life in her family." I didn't feel a need to search for outlets to escape from reality because I knew my family loved and supported me, and had a wonderful church family that also provided encouragement and support. Also, my grandparents (who raised me) did not talk about financial problems and other adult business in my presence. They would tell me to go upstairs when they had private things to talk about. I later found out they didn't want to worry me, but wanted me to experience a childhood free from the burdens that they felt only adults should have to worry about. These are only a few reasons why I think I had a good experience growing up as an African American female.
Posted by Vickie Howell | June 10, 2007 11:37 PM
Posted on June 10, 2007 23:37
Beth,
The story you told of the boy's mother coming into the classroom was interesting. I wonder when race, gender, and orientation will become a non-issue. Do you think there will ever be a day when people will just be accepted for who they are on the inside? It sounds like a tall order, but this is what I wish for.
I applaud you for teaching a lesson dealing the issue and next time you will be ready. We live in interesting times. I am somewhat optimistic about what could be in the future.
Laura Wollpert
Posted by Laura Wollpert | June 11, 2007 11:22 AM
Posted on June 11, 2007 11:22
Though it must have been difficult at the time, I am glad that you regrouped and presented a lesson on diversity in response to the students' questions. I think people who are biracial are becoming more and more present in the minority, and schools are going to need to respond to this difference.
Posted by Prof. Alecia Jackson | June 11, 2007 9:04 PM
Posted on June 11, 2007 21:04
I really don't think that there will ever be a day when race or gender is not an issue. Untill we as a government and political view stop subgrouping everyone into different groups of statistics, we as an individual will not stop doing so. I wish that I could say that I haven't at some time or another thought of someone on some sort of bias at one time or another. These things will continue to creep up on us until we as a nation do not see race or gender or ethnicity as a "subgroup". What steps should we be taking to go in that direction, I can not answer, but hopefully with each passing day we come closer to the solution.
Posted by Kristen Billings | June 11, 2007 9:45 PM
Posted on June 11, 2007 21:45