« Sara Joyce -Working Class Girlhoods | Main | Memories of Working-Class Girlhoods-Renee Pagoota »

Memories of Working Class Girlhoods

As I read this chapter, just as many of my other classmates, I really began to identify with childhoods of these women. I found it interesting how each of the woman's memories about her childhood significantly involved her mother. I am interested to read memories of a woman who grew up without a mother, because my mother spent much of her childhood without her mother. I am interested to see if the stories of their "girlhoods" would be similar to my mother's or if these women's "girlhoods" would be different than mine.

I bring this up in my blog, because I believe that my childhood was directly affected by my mother's childhood experiences. My mother's mother passed away of cancer when my mother was in elementary school. She was the youngest of three children, and her stories often break my heart. She says growing up they didn't have books, and her father was often consumed in other activites and so there was very little emphasis on school at home. Not too long after my mother's mother died, my grandfather began dating again. He later remarried, a woman who was cruel to my mother, leaving my mother more alone than ever. My mother really struggled in school, and she often told me this as a child. She was miserable in high school, and told me she was the student that would hide during lunch and eat in the bathroom. Academically she did not do well, and when I was younger I remember that she showed me her report card. School was hard for her, and I could tell she did not want it to be hard for me. Thus, my mother emphasized learning, reading, and books. My childhood was consumed with trips to the library and the bookstore. I feel my mother wanted everything for me that she didn't have. As Hicks writes in her book about the mentality of the "good girl", this made me think about myself. I wanted to please my mother so much I often think it came from the fact that I wanted to live and be everything my mother wasn't able to be as a child. I wanted to live her dreams. I didn't want her to "suffer" again with my school experience, as she did when she was a child, so I achieved and was successful. I made good grades, loved school, and was the "good girl" to the teachers.

My mother is a teacher, and now always tells me, " I always knew you would be a teacher". Sometimes I wonder if I would have become one if it wasn't drilled into me during my childhood. I never wanted to disappoint my parents, thus I always did well in school. In my mind, it was what I was "supposed to do". Frame says she" connected to desires voiced by her mother". I felt my mother's desires were not necessarily voiced as her desires, but instead she was showing me the things she wasn't, so that I could do those things. This instilled in me the idea that I had to achieve those things, first for my mother, then for myself. Now, as an adult, I wonder if I would have worked just as hard to achieve my successes for my father, as I did for my mother. For my father I was successful athletically, for my mother I was successful academically. I wanted to make both my parents proud, but primarily my mother. I wonder again, how do the "girlhoods" of girls without mothers differ from those girlhoods of girls with mothers? How would this girlhood experience then shape literacy learning?

Sarah McMillan

Comments (5)

Lisa Outland:

Sarah-
I could relate to your post where you mentioned your mother was a teacher. Although mine did not want me to be a teacher, I think it was her desire for me to do anything else that pushed me to be a teacher. Maybe she had a little reverse psychology working on me. However, I think if you are a teacher’s child, you just know you are supposed to be the good kid. I am not sure I had another choice than to be the good kid and try to excel at everything I tried. But then again, I had the double whammy of having both parents as teachers and I knew I didn’t have an inch to mess with if I wasn’t being the good kid.

Beth Rigsbee:

Sarah,
These are good thoughts about girls who don't have a mother. I wonder too what life would have been like if my mother had not encouraged me in school. I feel most fathers just do not understand the importance of academics at home. They work on the athletics with the children and the mothers work on the academics. This is not to say that a single dad cannot raise a wonderful student. I know fathers can and some do stress academics, but a lot do not. Also, some students are not strong academically and cannot do work on their own. Therefore, they need more assistance than someone who is stronger academically. The stronger academic student would have an easier time in school because they would require less assistance from a parent.

Beth Rigsbee

Andrea Lehman:

Sarah,
Those are good questions....i've often wondered the same: " How do the "girlhoods" of girls without mothers differ from those girlhoods of girls with mothers?" Also, i'll add to that....How are children changed when they have neither parent? I often wonder how children who are orphans make it in life. I just can't imagine it.

I was pushed academically as well by my mother, and athletically by my father. I was a big tom-boy! I wonder why many fathers don't push academics quite as much?

Your story about your mom was heartbreaking! All i could think about was Cinderella. I used to play that as a child, but can't imagine it in reality. I'm sure it changed your mother and i'm sure it had a big impact on you as well. Good post.

Prof. Alecia Jackson:

Sarah,
What a terrific question at the conclusion of your post. I think "mothering" has changed in significant ways in this new generation (of women in their 20s, 30s & 40s). I'm wondering how a new generation of mothering -- on the tail end of feminism -- will influence girls in schools. Will the "good girl" look the same as it did 20 years ago? Do girls experience more identity crises than they did 20 years ago? I teach mostly young women, and I see them so differently than I was at 21 and 22. I have to wonder how their mothers have shaped their lives -- if they try to fulfill their mothers' dreams instead of their own. I guess I should ask them!

Hi! Just wanted to tell you that I really like your entire writing style and that so I'm going to follow this blog continually from now :) Keep it up!

Post a comment

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on June 8, 2007 12:38 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Sara Joyce -Working Class Girlhoods.

The next post in this blog is Memories of Working-Class Girlhoods-Renee Pagoota.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35