As I read Chapter 3 I began to feel better about the book. Chapter 3 was easier to read and perhaps because I made a connection to it. As Ms. Hicks described her early literacy experiences, having been raised in a Christian home many of her experiences mimicked my own. I had not previously thought of those Bible school days as literacy experiences.
Farther into the chapter, I felt agreement with Ms. Miller's idea that a child's identity is formed by their relationship with their mother. As I grew up my mother was the homemaker and the person my brother and I spent the most time with. My father worked and was viewed as more the disciplinarian in our home. If we got into mischief, although she discussed it with us immediately we had to wait until Dad came home for the consequence. I realize now how that scenario set the stage for how we viewed our future roles as adults. I have to question however, whether my agreement doesn't stem from my own personal experience and because I have students from single parent households if that still rings true today?
My mother has never been a reader other than the newspaper but she did encourage reading in our home. She bought books that she felt would be helpful to us as students. She convinced my Dad to purchase a set of Encyclopedias and the Childcraft series from a traveling salesman. She also purchased a People of the Bible series and I read them all being interested in people and history. I could relate to the author in using reading as an escape. As I grew older I reading became an escape from boredom or having to watch a shared TV, usually a show I wasn't interested in. To this day I spend more time reading than watching TV.
Much like Ms. Hicks I learned early how to please my teachers and worked hard at conforming to their and my parent's expectations. I enjoyed reading about her tutored student and the rewarding trip to Borders. I agree with her that in reading and writing their is a world of endless possibilities.
As teachers it is always easier to engage a student with whom you share a common interest or history, however, the trick is to find a commonality with those other students to share with them the freedom that language arts can bring. Perhaps delving into their earlier literacy experiences could be the key to open that door. This chapter has me thinking about ways to do that.
Comments (6)
Sara, chapter 3 was much easier to read then the first two chapters. I think part of it could have been the connections we were able to make to it. I to was able to relate to most of what Hicks described in this chapter. I felt almost like I was reading about my own life. I found that to be very interesting.
I do believe children’s identities are formed by their relationship with their mother. I believe this could be try for boys as well. I wonder why that is? Maybe it has something to do with a woman having a baby and for some reason that child and his/her mother are connected in some way. I am not sure if this is true or if there is any truth behind it. I do not have children, but I have three sisters and a brother. Even though I see some my father’s qualities in my brother, I can also see how he and my mom relate to each other. My mom was the homemaker to in our house while my dad was on the road driving trucks. Everything we learned we learned from her. She made sure we read and had plenty to read. Even with my brother and my reading problems, she was the one who had to work with us to getting our reading skills up to were they needed to be. She has truly played an important part in my literacy experience.
I thought the way Hicks’ was able to get the child she was tutoring interested in reading was good. I wonder how we can make language arts and reading more interesting for students. If we could take children to Borders or set up some a reading program that would create more interest in reading, I think it would motivate our boys and girls to read more and learn things they never imagined possible.
Posted by Danielle Griffin | June 10, 2007 5:05 PM
Posted on June 10, 2007 17:05
sara,
i could relate to so much of what you wrote. my mother too stayed home with my siblings and me. she was the person that we spent most of our time with. dad was at work and he was the boss...there and at home! if we got in trouble with mom while dad was at work, we knew that when dad got home we were really going to be in worse trouble.
my mom was also the caregiver that got us books. my mom ordered so many great books and magazines and encylopedias...so many great things came to the house. she also took us to the library and waited as we went through books. then there were the 4h club summer fun classes and all those art kits she would buy. she also took us to church every sunday.
we too had one tv...no remote control...my children think i lived in the stone age. when dad came home we all had to be quiet and leave the living room because dad wanted to watch the news.
it is amazing how much our caregivers mold us into who we will become.
donna byrd-wyatt
Posted by donna byrd-wyatt | June 11, 2007 11:29 AM
Posted on June 11, 2007 11:29
Sara,
I like you could connect with Hick's chapter since I too was raised in a Christian home. I too had never thought about those Bible days as literary experiences, but it makes a lot of sense. My two year old is in Bible School this week and I feel good about knowing I am shaping his literary knowledge. I had never really considered how the discipline we received from our parents shapes who we are. But to answer your question, even in single parent households, those parents are using discipline that helps that child become who they are. I was not in a single parent household, but have had friends that where who became successful adults.
You are so right in that it seems easy to engage students who we share commalities with. My challenge this year for myself is to read and research customs and beliefs about the students in my classroom that come from other cultures.
Linda Younts
Posted by Linda Younts | June 11, 2007 2:17 PM
Posted on June 11, 2007 14:17
Your last paragraph struck a chord with me. It's so important for teachers to try to connect with every child. Sometimes i have a hard time with this. It's hard when you don't automatically connect with a student. I had a little boy like that this year. He was quiet and never shared anything about his homelife. About half-way through the year, i started a morning routine called "campfire". The kids and i sat in a circle and passed a stick around. Everyone was aloud to share one thing (the kids loved this and it got them to not talk as much during lessons). This one boy never shared. Finally, one day he spoke up and said his dad had to go to jail for the weekend. Whoa! Talk about caught off guard....plus i finally realized why he was so shy and quiet (he had a bad homelife). After that moment, i asked him how he was doing daily and really connected with him. If only i'd paid more attention at the beginning of the year, i know that he could have benefited. After that, he really started showing growth in all academic areas. It just goes to show that if kids have another person (their "other") that they can count on, it makes a world of difference in their literacy learning. Good post.
Posted by Andrea Lehman | June 11, 2007 8:24 PM
Posted on June 11, 2007 20:24
Sara,
I agree with you that tapping into those very early, very formative literacy experiences can open up a world for you in regard to knowing your students better. If you approach literacy as Hicks does and define it widely, I think you'll find that your students have a lot in common and then some very unique experiences related to race, class, and gender. What an amazing starting point for a school year!
Posted by Prof. Alecia Jackson | June 11, 2007 9:29 PM
Posted on June 11, 2007 21:29
I too agree that chapter three was easier to read than the first two. I understood much more this time around than I did reading the first two chapters. I actually understood a little more of the frist two chapters after readind this one.
I think that we do need to watch for each child and try to connect with each one individually not just the ones that are trying to be the "good girls." You never know when you will connect with a student who you thought was the trouble maker or the one that never participated. I can't wait till I can have my class again so that I can put these new thoughts into action.
Posted by Kristen Billings | June 11, 2007 10:05 PM
Posted on June 11, 2007 22:05